PDA

View Full Version : Probability difficulties and Z scores



Deganveran
02-27-2010, 05:36 PM
I am currently grappling with this question:

In a certain study the average age was 34.79 years. The SD of age was 14.78.

What probability do you have of observing someone 20 years old or younger?

I have determined that 20 years is a z score of 1.06.

However, here is what is throwing me off:

Is that -1.06 or positive?

And when looking at the unit normal table I am wondering if I am looking above Z or below z? I believe it is below z but the unit normal table is saying its 0.8554 or 85.54% chance of finding a 20 year old or younger probability at random. And that, I know is wrong as at least 75% should be within one standard deviation (or z = 1) of the mean.

Dragan
02-28-2010, 12:51 AM
I am currently grappling with this question:

In a certain study the average age was 34.79 years. The SD of age was 14.78.

What probability do you have of observing someone 20 years old or younger?

I have determined that 20 years is a z score of 1.06.

However, here is what is throwing me off:

Is that -1.06 or positive?


It is negative:

z=(20 - 34.79) / 14.78 = -1.000676...

Deganveran
02-28-2010, 01:48 PM
It is negative:

z=(20 - 34.79) / 14.78 = -1.000676...

As a follow up question . . . twenty of below (with a mean 34.79) would be below the z score right? That would be .8413 (84.13). Above the z score is 0.1587 (15.87). Above the mean looks like the right answer numerically but below looks right contextually.

Dragan
02-28-2010, 02:23 PM
As a follow up question . . . twenty of below (with a mean 34.79) would be below the z score right? That would be .8413 (84.13). Above the z score is 0.1587 (15.87). Above the mean looks like the right answer numerically but below looks right contextually.

I'm having a difficult time understanding your follow-up question.

However, in your original post you ask:

What probability do you have of observing someone 20 years old or younger?

As such, a Z-score of -1.0006 would correspond to a probability value of (approximately) p=0.1587. And, this prob. value would correctly answer the question.

Deganveran
02-28-2010, 04:52 PM
I'm having a difficult time understanding your follow-up question.

However, in your original post you ask:

What probability do you have of observing someone 20 years old or younger?

As such, a Z-score of -1.0006 would correspond to a probability value of (approximately) p=0.1587. And, this prob. value would correctly answer the question.

Ok, thank you.