Recent content by noetsi

  1. noetsi

    Why are so many variables in my regression significant?

    I don't know how this impacts significance exactly but spurious regression is very common in time series, when you are tracking relationships over time. If two variables have a trend built into them they can show high correlation even though they are not related. One thing to look for, is if you...
  2. noetsi

    What statistical method should I use to comapare variables over time?

    If you wanted to do something simple you could take the data (separately for each species and project forward several years) with exponential smoothing. You need at least 50 points of data. All the time series methods I know which show how one variable influences another over time are way to...
  3. noetsi

    Observational Study

    Some have questioned the validity of the data for this study https://news.yahoo.com/lancet-says-concerned-validity-widely-200507594.html.
  4. noetsi

    How to improve forecasting

    I do MAPE in excel. I don't know if proc arima does a mape automatically.
  5. noetsi

    Standard Multiple regression help

    What is the range of your dependent variable. From what to what. Violations of your assumptions won't impact the slope. They will influence the statistical test. There are a range of solutions for violation none are easy to do. Transformations of the data is the most common way to deal with the...
  6. noetsi

    Homogeneity requirements for Linear regression

    Generally speaking as the sample size gets larger violations of most (although not all) of the assumptions become less important. The results are asymptotically correct :p
  7. noetsi

    What is this time series coding doing

    My computer will not let me copy and paste formulas from that link or code. I am not sure why this occurs. Thanks for explaining what the [] does. One problem with OTEST is the authors assume you know a fair amount of R already.
  8. noetsi

    What is this time series coding doing

    (fit<-auto.arima(uschange[,"Consumption],xreg=uschange[,"Income])) It is what is in the brackets that I am asking about I don't know what it is doing. It is figure 9.1 in the link below. https://otexts.com/fpp2/regarima.html
  9. noetsi

    Problem with package

    We have significant seasonality in our data. The otext suggested that processing days could explain much of this seasonality (in our case, days per month more generally for other phenomenon). I was trying to standardize our data by dividing spending by the days per month for a given month...
  10. noetsi

    Observational Study

    Since events occur after random assignment, and individuals drop out of studies, you are always going to have confounds.
  11. noetsi

    Minimum population size for statistical tests?

    If you think that you have the population then you can ignore statistical tests. Whatever the effect size you find, that is the true effect size. So p values, sample size etc are entirely unimportant. I would not even report statistical tests in this case.
  12. noetsi

    Problem with package

    I don't know its a function in the forecast package. I looked it up, but I don't understand the documentation. https://www.rdocumentation.org/packages/forecast/versions/8.12/topics/monthdays
  13. noetsi

    Standard Multiple regression help

    Are your predictor variables ordinal. And what is your dependent variable - how is it coded. I am guessing your dependent variable is not interval which is a problem if true given you appear to be running linear regression. You don't have a lot of data given what your standardized predicted...
  14. noetsi

    Dealing with definition changes mid time series

    Well first you want to analyze if there is a structural break at that period. Something like a chow test. If there is one you normally analyze the data separately within the different periods. Essentially you have a new process so past data is of little value before the break.
  15. noetsi

    Observational Study

    I was asking about the validity of these kind of tests in general. How much confidence can we put in observational studies. And Hlsmith addressed. No statistical test, including ones with random assignment can get rid of the possibility of confounds. Some are better than others.