# Thread: Comparing the mean of two non-random groups

1. ## Comparing the mean of two non-random groups

Students are assigned to group A or B based on two aspects: a grade from an exam and an evaluation of their teacher. Students with both a high grade and a positive evaluation get into group A, other students in group B. I know that the grade is much more influential than the teacher’s evaluation.

I have the exam grades of 1,000 students. I also know whether students are assigned to group A or B.

I want to know whether the average grade of students in group A is higher than the average grade in group B.

where Grade(i) is the grade of student i. Dum_A(i) equals 1 if student i is in group A and 0 otherwise.

Do students in group A have a higher grade if Alfa is significant according to a standard t-test? Note that students in group A tend to have a higher grade since assignment is mostly based on the grade. It seems to me that the dummy is endogenous and thus the estimate of Alfa is incorrect. Is my interpretation correct?

Does this mean that it is not possible to compare the mean of the two groups? Are there any alternatives?

Any thoughts are very much appreciated!

2. ## Re: Comparing the mean of two non-random groups

I am still struggling with this issue.

Any guidance would be very much appreciated!

 Tweet

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts