# Thread: Show, by calculation, that the mean of y doesn't exist

1. ## Show, by calculation, that the mean of y doesn't exist

This is one of my questions for my homework, I have attached a copy of the function and also my attempt, I'm not sure if I've done it right. And if I have, why does the answer suggest that the mean of y doesn't exist? I understand that if the function is infinite, then it has no mean, however I don't understand why this answer would suggest that it has no mean?

2. ## Re: Show, by calculation, that the mean of y doesn't exist

First of all you need the marginal pdf by integrating out first, i.e.

Let you try first before discussing the remaining integration issue.

3. ## Re: Show, by calculation, that the mean of y doesn't exist

So this is the marginal pdf

after this do i do the second integration? or is there another step in between?

4. ## Re: Show, by calculation, that the mean of y doesn't exist

I just did it quickly on my whiteboard. Is this how it's supposed it be?

5. ## Re: Show, by calculation, that the mean of y doesn't exist

The marginal pdf you got in #3 is correct. If you are familiar with Gamma pdf you can very quickly to obtain that answer without integration by part.

It shows that the marginal pdf is a Pareto distribution, or the Lomax distribution with parameter

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lomax_distribution

You should continue with the marginal pdf and obtain the answer (Or if you know the survival function it could help too). Not quite follow what you did in the last post.

6. ## Re: Show, by calculation, that the mean of y doesn't exist

Unfortunately we haven't learnt the other methods as of yet, so I've stuck with the marginal pdf approach. I've attached what I've done, and just wanted confirmation on whether I've done it right.