# Thread: chi square with percentages

1. ## chi square with percentages

Hello
I have two sample with a very different size (n=42 and n=282) and I only know the percentages of the dependent variable (with 8 levels).

The difference between the two sample in each level of DV is very large (for example: in the first condition the percentages are 16% and 82% respectively).

I converted the percentages in observed frequencies (for example 16/100*42; 82/100*282; ect.). I performed a chi square 2x8 with spss and the p-value is not significant.
How it is possible that p-value is not significant if the differences between the frequencies of each condition are vary large? This is not the procedure to be followed when you only have the percentages?

2. ## Re: chi square with percentages

Your approach seems fine. Can you post your final constructed 2X8 table so we can provide a better response on the rationale?

Thanks.

3. ## Re: chi square with percentages

Originally Posted by hlsmith
Can you post your final constructed 2X8 table so we can provide a better response on the rationale?

Thanks.
I posted a xlsx file with 2x8 table. Thanks.

4. ## Re: chi square with percentages

Sorry, I don't open online files

What could be happening is that the test is under-powered, given the two distributions are truly different.

5. ## Re: chi square with percentages

Originally Posted by hlsmith
test is under-powered.
sorry, what does it mean. test is not correct?

6. ## Re: chi square with percentages

It would mean the two distributions (proportions for categories) are truly different, but you do not have enough data to make this conclusion. This would be a Type II Error, failing to reject the null hypothesis of no difference in distributions in the sample when the two distributions are truly different in the population.

7. ## Re: chi square with percentages

thanks vary musch. Can I performe a different statistic to see if I have the same result?

 Tweet

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts