+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: Simple "controlling for population size difference" question

  1. #1
    Points: 1,584, Level: 22
    Level completed: 84%, Points required for next Level: 16

    Posts
    12
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts

    Simple "controlling for population size difference" question




    Hello,

    I just had a ludicrous argument with a friend that we would like your help on settling. Let's assume the following:

    California population: 100,000
    Nevada population: 60,000

    # of toy cars in California: 300
    # of toy cars in Nevada: 200

    comparing the number of toy cars in california v. nevada would be unfair due to the difference in population size. But by proportioning the number of toy cars per 5000 citizens, you can have a fairer comparison.

    300/(100,000/5000)=15
    200/(60,000/5000)= 16.66

    When controlling for the difference in population size, we can see that Nevada in a sense has more toy cars per 5000 population than california and comparing 15 v. 16.66 would in a sense be "fair" or at least fairer (without becoming too nuanced)

    How is this wrong? I don't understand his argument.

  2. #2
    Omega Contributor
    Points: 38,432, Level: 100
    Level completed: 0%, Points required for next Level: 0
    hlsmith's Avatar
    Location
    Not Ames, IA
    Posts
    7,006
    Thanks
    398
    Thanked 1,186 Times in 1,147 Posts

    Re: Simple "controlling for population size difference" question

    Your logic is good enough. No idea what the counter-argument is, if it is not focusing on controlling for even more details (e.g., age, gender, etc.).


    There is a fallacy similar to this. I can't remember the name, but the traditional example usually says something like you are more likely to get in a wreck with a white car than red car. The hitch is there are more white cars.
    Stop cowardice, ban guns!

  3. The Following User Says Thank You to hlsmith For This Useful Post:

    feignfeign (06-03-2016)

  4. #3
    TS Contributor
    Points: 12,287, Level: 72
    Level completed: 60%, Points required for next Level: 163
    rogojel's Avatar
    Location
    I work in Europe, live in Hungary
    Posts
    1,471
    Thanks
    160
    Thanked 332 Times in 312 Posts

    Re: Simple "controlling for population size difference" question


    I think this depends on the interpretation of the rather vague term "more". If somebody is interested in the absolute number as in revenue generated by selling toy cars then obviously california is the winner, If the interest is in where do people like toy cars more then nevada , and both answers are right So, as very often in stats this boils down to what the research question is.

+ Reply to Thread

           




Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts






Advertise on Talk Stats