Paired samples with competition

#1
Hi all,

I have abit of a puzzle that at first may seem straightforward but I believe there is a complication.

I have a paired design with each subject being a pot containing 2 plants, 1 treated and 1 untreated. Note that the treatments are applied before planting so they so not run onto the other plant. The problem is that the two plants in the pot compete. My understanding is that a paired t-test makes the assumption that the two plants in the same pot are not independent but I also believe that a paired t-test assumes that the result for one plant does not directly affect the result for the other. Any suggestions as to whether this is a valid layout and if so what analysis can be done?

Thanks
 

rogojel

TS Contributor
#2
hi,
It does seem a bit problematic, but I think it could be ok in the end. If there is no reason to suspect that the treated ones are sytematically better/worse then the untreated ones the effect of the competition should average out.

regards
rogojel
 

rogojel

TS Contributor
#4
Thanks Rogojel. The key objective is to compare treated and untreated though so if there was a true effect then it wouldn't cancel out.

Emily
hi,
you mean the treatment effect will not cancel out. The effect of the competition on the other hand will, so the experiment should be ok.

regards
rogojel
 
Last edited: